Page 1 of 1

Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 02 May 2013, 15:10
by Certus
Hi!
First of all i'm new here but maybe some ppl know me from game :P I decided to become map maker for multiplayer games, mostly because there is only few good maps to play on. Forgotten Lands is my first map for 4 players ( 2 extra slots for spectacors ).
This is finished version:
http://speedy.sh/MUaBA/Forgotten-Lands-fix2.rar

ss for lazy ppl:
whole map:
Image
loc 1:
Image
loc 2:
Image
loc 3:
Image
loc 4:
Image
middle of the map:
Image

Thanks to Bo_co and Bon for helping me with tests.
Tell me guys what do you think about this map :)

Enjoy!

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 02 May 2013, 17:26
by sado1
Screens would be nice. Although I already can say from what I saw before, that I don't like the way you elevate the terrain with randomize tool. But that might be my only complaint, I like the map.

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 02 May 2013, 17:31
by The Dark Lord
Yeah could you provide some screenshots? Many people are too lazy to download the map... Including myself...

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 02 May 2013, 18:25
by kocsis1david
The elevation is a bit strange, but the whole map still looks nice.

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 02 May 2013, 18:42
by Ben
Wow, this map is actually pretty good! My biggest complaint is the ridiculous amount of trees. Honestly, I think that all trees on the map need to be removed and placed better/ more "organized." Idk, it's pretty hard to explain. Some trees don't look good on certain terrain, and some trees (like the pine trees) don't look good next to other the kind of trees.
Look at TDL maps to see better trees. Other than that; though, the map looks very good :)

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 02 May 2013, 21:38
by Certus
Thanks guys for opinions and advices.
Wow, this map is actually pretty good! My biggest complaint is the ridiculous amount of trees.
Well in my opinion this maps looks good because of this ridiculous amount of objects including trees.
and some trees (like the pine trees) don't look good next to other the kind of trees.
Fixed.

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 02 May 2013, 22:09
by Ben
Well infinite wood is a side effect of spamming trees ;) Besides, crazy object spam doesn't look good. Here, there are a bit too many trees; however, since you adjusted the trees, it may look better.

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 04 May 2013, 11:24
by Leeuwgie
Very good looking map Certus, you are pretty talented. Your style looks like a mix between TDL's and Thunders style of mapmaking to me. My 2 cents:

+ terrain usage is perfect
+ nice mountains (and elevation in general)
+ looks balanced at first sight
+ open!
+ enough buildingspace
+ not all resources in starting/one screen
+ starting resources are perfect (maybe consider 10 more chests to allow setting up 2 schools from start)

- some coalfields are too far away
- mountains could be elevated a little bit more
- some sharp edged tiles are present

A lot of trees on the map, but not too much imo...

To

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 04 May 2013, 13:48
by Lewin
Nice work :)
I'll add it to the Remake. If you make any updates let us know.

Re: Forgotten Lands

PostPosted: 05 May 2013, 20:37
by Certus
Thanks for your opinions and advices :)

This is final version of this map:
http://speedy.sh/2XAHY/Forgotten-Lands.rar

I fixed few issues like sharp edged tiles and removed a few trees.

Enjoy!