Page 5 of 6
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 07 Oct 2014, 07:59
by Esthlos
just slowing down the reload, a very effective
In my opinion this would be very effective indeed... if instead of let's say 10 hits in 10 seconds the siege machine could do the same damage to buildings with 2 hits while needing to load its ammo for 5 seconds after stopping to shoot, it would maintain its usefulness against buildings but be useless against troops.
About "magical" moving Sieges:
I highly doubt this to be an actual problem... after all, nothing forbids to make Siege Workshops work like Stables, producing a ware that needs to be moved to the Barracks and then manned by a recruit in order to be used.
Also, starting from the existing sprites it shouldn't be very hard to add a recruit manning the siege machines.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 12 Nov 2014, 09:31
by Rhaenon
Also, starting from the existing sprites it shouldn't be very hard to add a recruit manning the siege machines.
Actually, it is pretty hard and a lot of work. I have tried to do this in the past (my username used to be Kridge) and it sure as hell wasn't easy. Keep in mind that it is a ton of sprites for going one direction, can't remember the exact number (I believe 8) and then you also have to do this in 8 directions (8*8=64 sprites).
Furthermore you would have to fit 2 units into a single tile, this causes size restrictions.
But maybe I'm just inexperienced and this is why I didn't succeed.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 12 Nov 2014, 17:21
by Ben
No, you're [Raenon] right: It is very hard. The artwork needs to be professional and (perhaps even harder) identical to the artwork of KaM.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 12 Nov 2014, 17:44
by Esthlos
The artwork needs to be professional and (perhaps even harder) identical to the artwork of KaM.
Ok, with this premise it would indeed be hard.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 13 Nov 2014, 15:28
by Rhaenon
Theoretically you can just use the sprites that are already there but yeah, even still.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 14 Nov 2014, 00:47
by Ben
Sprites that are already there? What is the recruit going to just walk behind the seige weapons as they move themselves? :S
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 14 Nov 2014, 16:48
by zombie01
Sprites that are already there? What is the recruit going to just walk behind the seige weapons as they move themselves? :S
offcourse not, they walk in front like pulling them.
we just need to create a rope around their middle
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 14 Nov 2014, 17:12
by Ben
You wouldn't pull catapult with a little rope, you'd push it with at least a couple of people. Not to mention that using current sprites of recruits walking would look terrible! I can imagine him lazily holding a string as a pony walks by his side...but not a siege machine.
It would be better to have them move magically, imo.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 16 Nov 2014, 18:03
by Rhaenon
You wouldn't pull catapult with a little rope, you'd push it with at least a couple of people. Not to mention that using current sprites of recruits walking would look terrible! I can imagine him lazily holding a string as a pony walks by his side...but not a siege machine.
It would be better to have them move magically, imo.
As I remember *cough* long time ago *cough* it looked okay-ish because the recruit was partly hidden behind the catapult or ballista but anyways.
The point about it was, even when modifieing these existing sprites;
It takes:
- Time
- Skill
- Dedication
- Consistency
Quick mockups are easy, even doing a single direction would be doable. But then there are things as shooting animations, creating every single direction etc.
That is all I wanted to say.
It is possible, I am convinced. But it takes the most valuable of all: time.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 18 Nov 2014, 10:54
by Kamykos
We should make animation for making people in KaM, because when they come out of school with only gold provided, it is not realistic.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 18 Nov 2014, 12:02
by zombie01
We should make animation for making people in KaM, because when they come out of school with only gold provided, it is not realistic.
we are already troubled by making sprites for a guy pushing a catapult.
other sprites are not a priorit at all
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 18 Nov 2014, 18:02
by Kamykos
Yes but how gold can make people? It is ridicolous. I mean it can when a rich man meets a greedy lady but still...
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 18 Nov 2014, 20:00
by dicsoupcan
good idea, we'll remove the school.
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 18 Nov 2014, 20:04
by Vatrix
Yes but how gold can make people? It is ridicolous. I mean it can when a rich man meets a greedy lady but still...
Maybe it's not making people from gold, but just hiring them? Think before you post sth like this!
And about removing school, I think it's a the best idea ever, can you even imagine how much fun will be with only two buildings?
Re: Regarding siege workshop and town hall
PostPosted: 18 Nov 2014, 23:48
by Kamykos
Yes but how gold can make people? It is ridicolous. I mean it can when a rich man meets a greedy lady but still...
Maybe it's not making people from gold, but just hiring them? Think before you post sth like this!
And about removing school, I think it's a the best idea ever, can you even imagine how much fun will be with only two buildings?
Okay, but still are they sitting in some basement and learning stuff? Like butcher is learning to make sausages in theory?
What if you think about machines as ents with wheels? Ents can move so how is it not normal?
